Tuesday, 7 May 2013

It takes a lot to make me this angry. A hell of a lot. Usually, I just get mad, throw some stuff and calm down pretty quickly. This anger is different- it's cold and it's burning at the back of my skull and I've been home an hour and I'm listening to my favourite song of the minute on constant repeat (here, if you're interested) and it's still prickling in my veins. I still have an overwhelming urge to hit someone, and all the pictures of cute cats in suits in the world can't make it go away.
See, I go to student council (not because I'm a councillor or anything, but because I'm a massive nerd and also some of the members are easy on the eye and because free pizza), and the democratic process genuinely excites me- I like that decisions made by our elected representatives can effect our whole educational experience, and I like the debate and the banter, and I like the procedure (okay, I'm a huge nerd- sue me?).
And tonight, the actions of the members of QUB's student council disappointed me beyond belief.I still can't believe it. I'm still angry about it. And I'm used to being disappointed and let down by people who are meant to represent me- I'm queer in Northern Ireland, for god's sake, and I cried on and off for a good hour after the equal marriage act was defeated last week- so the fact that I feel so drastically let down by 90 odd teenagers and very young adults ought to tell you something.
They're elected to represent their constituents- i.e. regular students, like you and me, who care more about stuff like getting good degree classifications and getting into the first team for a sport or hoping that that girl they've been crushing on for ages notices them just once, rather than student politics (okay, maybe students more like you than me, because as above Giant Nerd), and tonight they didn't do that.
At least thirty people left before the meeting was even halfway through, depriving their constituents of a voice. And not even for a reason, but because it was sunny and warm and there were barbecues to go to and boys without shirts on to gently flirt with. And trust me, everyone understands that temptation- I certainly do- but they were elected to represent you. And they decided that staying to discuss things that can drastically affect the lives of regular students wasn't worth it.
And as if that wasn't bad enough, council started to discuss a series of amendments to the union's constitution. Certain members of council (I won't name and shame, because it's easy enough to find out and I don't want to be responsible for hate) objected to the amendments, and instead of staying and discussing them like civilised sensible adults, they walked out, causing the numbers of council members present to fall below the number required to pass amendments, not only causing the failure of the amendment they objected  to, but preventing the discussion of a whole pile of other amendments that were really, really good ideas that could improve the lives of the regular student.
In my opinion, this was a selfish and despicable act that should be widely condemned. They are there to represent the student, not let political point scoring and a dislike of one particular motion take over. I truly, deeply hope that they fail to be elected again next year, because they are not worthy of the title of your representatives.

2 comments:

  1. Suppose the proposed constitutional amendment had been to ban anyone LGBTQ+ from accessing university facilities (let's pretend the SU a) has that much power and b) has been infiltrated by a reactionary conspiracy). Would it then have been acceptable to leave the meeting and thus prevent the amendment's passing? If your answer is "Yes" in that case, then your objection to the reps who left in order to scupper the amendment seems to be primarily a matter of how important and/or beneficial the amendment is, and consistency would suggest that the same ire should be applied to anyone with the temerity to vote against this motion. This seems odd if you are truly in favour of democracy.

    If, instead, you take the view that "they have voluntarily taken up this role, therefore they have a duty to go to meetings and vote thoughtfully, regardless of the motion at hand" - well then fine, but I doubt that this is the generally held view among students concerned with student council politics. So far as I can tell, most see it as a way of bettering your CV, having a bit of subsidised enjoyment, etc. I don't think that this view is necessarily a good one to hold, but I would guess that it is the dominant one. Certainly, those who left in order to drink beer on the lawns are likely to hold such views.

    You may well be right to be angry at what happened: the question is whether you are angry at anyone who would oppose this amendment, or at the view of student politics that most people hold.

    ATP

    ReplyDelete
  2. I take the second view- in my opinion, councillors are elected to go to meetings, discuss and vote thoughtfully, and they should do so, regardless of the motion. If an amendment like that had been proposed, I of course would have been fuming, but I would have hoped that through rational discussion in council it would have failed, and if it did pass I'd rather take the union to court, rather than ignore democracy and support an abandonment of accountability through a mass walk out.
    I believe in democracy above all else, and I believe in representation and the lack of this yesterday caused my anger, not the failure of the proposed amendment.

    ReplyDelete